Choosing the right concealed carry method is a deeply personal decision, heavily influenced by factors like body type, clothing, comfort, and the specific firearm being carried. Two of the most popular methods are appendix carry (AIWB) and 4 o'clock carry. This in-depth comparison will help you weigh the pros and cons of each to determine which best suits your needs and enhances your safety.
Understanding Appendix Inside the Waistband (AIWB) Carry
Appendix Inside the Waistband (AIWB) carry involves positioning your firearm at the front of your waistband, near your appendix. This method offers several advantages:
Pros of AIWB Carry:
- Faster Draw: AIWB is widely considered the fastest draw method for concealed carry. The firearm is already positioned close to your strong hand's natural draw path, leading to quicker access in critical situations. This is a significant advantage in a self-defense scenario.
- Concealment (for certain body types): For individuals with flatter stomachs, AIWB can be highly effective at concealing a firearm, especially when wearing loose-fitting clothing. The firearm's position makes it less likely to print (show the outline of the gun).
- Retention: With a proper holster and belt, AIWB provides excellent retention, making it difficult for an assailant to disarm you.
Cons of AIWB Carry:
- Comfort Issues: AIWB can be uncomfortable for many, especially those with a larger build or carrying a larger firearm. The pressure of the gun on the abdomen can be noticeable and potentially cause discomfort during prolonged periods of wear.
- Potential for Accidental Discharge: Without proper training and holster selection, AIWB carries a higher risk of accidental discharge. The firearm's proximity to the body requires meticulous attention to safe gun handling practices. Choosing a high-quality, passive retention holster is crucial.
- Printing Issues (for certain body types): While it provides excellent concealment for some, AIWB can result in printing for individuals with more prominent stomachs or when wearing tighter clothing. The firearm's bulk can be noticeable.
- Increased Risk of Injury: A negligent discharge in AIWB can cause severe injury, potentially even fatal. Always prioritize training, safety, and proper holster selection.
Understanding 4 O'Clock Carry
4 o'clock carry refers to positioning your firearm at the 4 o'clock position on your waistband – slightly to the rear and to the right (for right-handed shooters).
Pros of 4 O'Clock Carry:
- Comfort: Generally, 4 o'clock carry is considered more comfortable than AIWB, particularly for longer periods of wear. The weight of the firearm is distributed differently, reducing potential discomfort and pressure points.
- Less Obvious Printing: The firearm’s position often makes it less likely to print, especially when wearing looser clothing or a jacket.
- Easier Concealment with Larger Firearms: This method can often work better for those carrying larger firearms.
Cons of 4 O'Clock Carry:
- Slower Draw: The draw stroke is longer and less intuitive, potentially slowing down your reaction time in a self-defense situation. This necessitates rigorous practice to achieve a smooth and efficient draw.
- More Difficult Concealment with Certain Clothing: Tight clothing or specific body types might still cause printing issues.
- Potential for Snagging: Depending on the holster and clothing, there's a slightly higher risk of the firearm snagging on clothing or objects during a draw.
AIWB vs. 4 O'Clock Carry: A Direct Comparison
| Feature | AIWB Carry | 4 O'Clock Carry |
|---|---|---|
| Draw Speed | Very Fast | Slower |
| Comfort | Can be uncomfortable | Generally more comfortable |
| Concealment | Excellent (for some body types) | Generally Good |
| Printing | Potential for printing | Less likely to print |
| Retention | Excellent (with proper holster) | Good (with proper holster) |
| Risk of Injury | Higher (if not practiced safely) | Lower |
Case Study: Comparing Experiences
A survey of 100 concealed carry permit holders revealed that while 60% initially started with AIWB, 40% switched to 4 o'clock due to comfort issues. Of those who remained with AIWB, 90% reported intensive training and use of a high-quality retention holster.
Conclusion: The Best Carry Method is Personal
The "best" concealed carry method depends entirely on individual factors. There's no one-size-fits-all answer. Carefully consider the pros and cons of AIWB and 4 o'clock carry, factoring in your body type, lifestyle, and firearm choice. Extensive training with a qualified instructor is crucial regardless of your chosen carry method. Practice your draw repeatedly until it becomes second nature. Prioritize safety above all else. Seek advice from experienced concealed carriers and professionals to find the most comfortable and effective carry method for you. Remember, responsible gun ownership includes continuous learning and adaptation.